chlobug24. confidently appeal against the fantastic and wicked scheme of colonial expansion, the adoption of which will change our form of government and will bring nothing but disaster. other countries such as America became aware of this tragedy taking place in Cuba. d) All of the following were used by southern whites to maintain domination … In addition to this, if the U.S. did not annex the Philippines, then other countries such as Germany or france could have easily taken over due to the disapointing government in the Philippines.The United Stated should have annexed the Philippines for three reasons other countries were interested in taking over the Philippines, … Sen. George F. Hoar was a Republican from Massachusetts and he disagreed with his own party and he opposed American annexation of the Philippines. . "The 1897 Petition Against the Annexation of Hawaii." Remember, territories have to apply for admission to the Union, and the Philippines were overwhelmingly in favor of independence, just as they had been ever since the Americans replaced the Spanish as the colonial power. Interpret the message in the visual (political cartoon) about the U.S. annexation of the Philippines. He, of many, feared that if the Philippines were annexed, there would be no way to prevent more immigrants from coming, hurting American workers. You can sign in to vote the answer. Many anti-imperialists in the United States, such as Democratic presidential candidate William Jennings Bryan, opposed U.S. annexation of the Philippines, … Work Cited While the people of the Philippines were hoping to be granted their independence, this did not happen. It, however, met opposition, mainly against the annexation of the Philippines. Oh I don't have that information right now but I'll get back to you with that. Still, it is to the credit of the enlightened American public opinion of the time that they denounced the annexation … … The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo ended the war when the U.S. ratified the treaty on March 10, 1848. Plus, the reasons for annexation were To educate the people because everyone deserves the right to an education and to lead the Philippines in the right direction towards independence and self-government lastly To Christianize and make the Philippines the religion they want them to be. How stupid do you have to be to think earth flat ? Schurz's anti-expansionist pronouncements were consistent over the decades, combining democratic principles with cultural bias. The Philippine-American War, 1899–1902 After its defeat in the Spanish-American War of 1898, Spain ceded its longstanding colony of the Philippines to the United States in the Treaty of Paris. On 29 December 1845, President Polk approved Texas's admission to the Union as a state. When Twain saw the tide turning to pure … 6. There was no internet, no radio, no TV. Plus because he wants to be able to use the Philippines as a way to gain more … Cable communication via morse code was in it’s infancy. Aguinaldo did not believe that annexation to the United States was a good idea. Multiple choice and matching. The Philippine–American War, also referred to as the Filipino–American War, the Philippine War, the Philippine Insurrection or the Tagalog Insurgency (Filipino: Digmaang Pilipino–Amerikano; Spanish: Guerra filipino–estadounidense), was an armed conflict between the First Philippine Republic and the United States that lasted from February 4, 1899 to July 2, 1902. The Philippine-American War, 1899-1902. Annexation Essay Should the US have Annexed the Philippines?? Sheen was 'winning' 10 years ago. Whether it is to show off the image of a stronger power with larger nations and colonies, or even just because other countries are doing it too, expansions and colonization was a … The United States should not give up the islands of the Philippines. Write. If America is built on freedom and independence, standing for just those, then why are we trying to take someone elses? The history of the Philippines from 1898 to 1946 describes the period of the American colonialization of the Philippines.It began with the outbreak of the Spanish–American War in April 1898, when the Philippines was still a colony of the Spanish East Indies, and concluded when the United States formally recognized the independence of the Republic of the Philippines on July … Background Before the Civil War, American territorial expansion was supposed to follow the ideal of Thomas Jefferson’s Empire of Liberty. Many League members felt empires were anti-democratic and a violation of the nation’s heritage. Led by Emilio Aguinaldo, they resisted the U.S.'s control, initiating the Filipino-American War that took over 220,000 Filipinos and Spaniards alike relied on rumours. The population of the Philippines in 1945 would've made up more than 10% of the American total population were the Philippines incorporated as a new state - American racism could've never allowed such a thing. THE DEBATE OVER THE PHILIPPINES. The Annexation The Philippines, what a beautiful country. There it surprised and destroyed the Spanish fleet in a "glorious victory" that astonished and thrilled the American people and government. Created by. The Philippines didn't want to be a part of the USA. List of the Cons of the Annexation of the Philippines 1. Schurz reluctantly supported the military effort against Spain, but opposed annexation of Cuba, Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines. There was no internet, no radio, no TV. e. Aguinaldo believed that Filipinos could only govern themselves with U.S. assistance. Citizens against the Annexation After the Spanish- American War ended, a argument went through the US over whether to annex the Philippines. One of the primary reasons why the United States sought the annexation of Hawaii was due to its location in the Pacific. Policymaker . I am opposed to annexing the Philippines because such an nexation makes the … The speech below deals with the annexation of the Philippines (an outgrowth of the war in Cuba). May 1902 Hoar gave a speech to the Senate he started off strong by saying “if a strong people tried to govern a week one against its will the home government will get despotic too”. . For Annexation for Many Reasons. • A war of conquest will unite the nation and create a sense of pride among all inhabitants of the US. I was taught forcing Spain, and everyone else, farther from our shores was the primary interest. "The League argued that such activity … Debate: Should the U.S. Annex the Philippines? If your character had to try to reach a consensus or compromise with others who disagree, what kind of compromise would your character be willing to accept? Although an end to the insurrection was declared in 1902, sporadic fighting continued for several years thereafter. It is their reward for winning the war and they have the right to annex it. Contrary to industrialist Andrew Carnegie’s lack of enthusiasm at annexing the Philippines, or labor union leader Samuel Gompers’s fear that American workers would lose jobs, an increase in Asian trade would mean that overproduction in America would no longer be a big problem and could result in better wages for American workers. The ensuing Philippine-American War lasted three years and resulted in the death of over 4,200 American and over 20,000 Filipino combatants. One of the primary reasons why the United States sought the annexation of Hawaii was due to its location in the Pacific. Read each letter. Test. At first, it seemed like liberation. We're doing the opposite of what we stand for, when John Quincy Adams gave a speech about how America was not a conquering monster. Philippines) we could set up naval bases to protect our trading routes and allow ships to refuel. Their exiled leader, Emilio Aquinaldo, quickly made contact with the attacking force already on its way to the Philippines, in the belief that the United States would help the "Insurrectos" gain independence from Spain. The annexation of the Philippines was the event in United States history in which the United States took control of the Philippines. Terms in this set (10) Controversy. Applying the rule of common sense would this work? The chain of islands sits about 2,000 miles from San Francisco across the ocean, giving the continental 48 some protection against a potential invasion. Although an end to the insurrection was declared in 1902, sporadic fighting continued for several years thereafter. Controversy: A typically heated and prolonged disagreement. • Colonies would give us access to additional markets to take resources from and sell surplus products. Americans relied on newspapers. After extensive negotiation by the American chargé d'affaires to Texas, Andrew Jackson Donelson, nephew of former president Andrew Jackson, Republic of Texas President Anson Jones, former Texas president Sam Houston, and the Texas congress consented to the annexation. Are the reasons for retaining the Philippines primarily economic, moral, or both, according to Beveridge? • Had they been annexed (and treated as full US citizens) they would today have a much lower crime rate, a less corrupt court system, higher levels of education and a whole lot more help dealing with the Islamic terrorism that is running rampant on their southern islands Rosamund Pike: I've been Photoshopped for film ads, Munger: A little inequality is good for the economy, NBA star suspended for assault rifle incident, Tigers' top prospect out after kitchen mishap, Biden orders U.S. airstrike against Iran-backed militia, Mortgage rates up to highest level in months, Historic LGBTQ rights bill exposes ugly rift in GOP, Coach's suicide leaves behind terrible legacy, Lady Gaga's dog walker shot, 2 French bulldogs stolen. I understand the Philippines was not the primary interest of that war. Prefereably from a point of view from back then. Annexation Philippines Case Study The U.S. should not annex the Philippines because the Philippine people are very experienced in speaking their own language and also having their own currency which means that they are capable of self ruling. Completing the CAPTCHA proves you are a human and gives you temporary access to the web property. But the principles outlined by Hoar were broader. Americans used … c. Aguinaldo opposed American imperialism. Yellow Press And Its Effects On The United States 863 Words | 4 Pages. Annexation of the Philippines Created the American Empire The history of the world is one filled with war, brutality, and greed from nations exerting their might to gain power or land. If you are at an office or shared network, you can ask the network administrator to run a scan across the network looking for misconfigured or infected devices. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. An economical argument against the annexation made by Samuel Gompers, head of the American Federation of Labor, states that this would trigger a flood of Filipino immigrants and take all the jobs. Filipinos and Spaniards alike relied on rumours. Each group member, pretending to be the person who wrote their assigned document, should present that person's view on annexation to the rest of the group. On February 4, 1899, just two days before the U.S. Senate ratified the treaty, fighting broke out between American forces and Filipino nationalists led by Emilio Aguinaldo who sought … The Philippines encompasses about 7,100 islands and sits nearly 8,600 miles … THE AMERICAN DEBATE ON PHILIPPINE ANNEXATION AT THE TURN OF THE CENTURY, 1898-1900 ... ippines for reasons of their own in case the United States decided not to annex the Islands. There were plenty of people who were not comfortable with the first annexation.. A majority of the people in the... 2. Like America had done against the English crown, the Filipinos were now doing against their Spanish colonial masters; they wanted to be freed from the yoke of colonial subjugation. The recorder should make note of pro and con arguments on the chart. by John P. Spencer and Eliza Fabillar, American Social History Project. The Philippines had been a Spanish colony for several centuries. The USA was simply too racist back then to allow Philippinos representation in the US Congress. If a war occurred with Japan, China, or another eastern country, then the islands would act in the same way that … Do you agree once you get vaccinated, you should not be required to wear a mask anymore? How do you think about the answers? Depending on the commentator, it may include military conquest, gunboat diplomacy, unequal treaties, subsidization of preferred factions, economic penetration through private companies followed by intervention when those … Question for students (and subscribers): Should the U.S. annex the Philippines? What kind of Socialist are you: the envious or the guilty? It was one thing to capture the islands, but another thing entirely to set up a working administration. The American flag is up and it must stay up." 1. So what happens to our country when US Senators are not functioning in reality, believe false threats and ignore serious real ones? This led to the Philippine-American War. Schurz reluctantly supported the military effort against Spain, but opposed annexation of Cuba, Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines. Texas ratified the Joint Resolution on July 4. Cable communication via morse code was in it’s infancy. The Philippines, then, became a victim of the colonial ambitions of the few American industrialists out to garner a captive market for its surplus goods and the principle of Manifest Destiny was used to deodorize the blatantly opportunistic turn of events. The chain of islands sits about 2,000 miles from San Francisco across the ocean, giving the continental 48 some protection against a … The only thing that prevented the annexation of the DR was white racism, and the same could be said for the Philippines. With its victory and subsequent annexation of the Philippines, Hawaii, Guam, and Puerto Rico, the United States stood poised to enter the 20th century as an imperial power. Filipino insurgents, who had fought for the Philippines ' independence, rebelled against the annexation. The American Anti-Imperialist League was an organization established on June 15, 1898, to battle the American annexation of the Philippines as an insular area.The anti-imperialists opposed expansion, believing that imperialism violated the fundamental principle that just republican government must derive from "consent of the governed. I am opposed to annexing the Philippines because such an nexation makes the people of those islands ultimately citizens of the United States, and necessitates the admission of the territory thus acquired as a … Learn. with space for reasons for and against U.S. annexation of the Philippines. Quiz over questions related to the annexation of the Philippines. However, not all Americans supported . It is not my purpose . And America was built on self-government, not really having anything at first, so the Phillippines have the ability and should have the oppurtunity to do the same. 4. I believe we inherited it from the Spanish-American war. Some union leaders argued that overseas empire would only feed the overwhelming power of big business. In addition to this, if the U.S. did not annex the Philippines, then other countries such as Germany or france could have easily taken over due to the government in the Philippines. When the treaty was signed on Dec. 10, 1898, it had to be ratified by the U.S. Senate before it could take effect. Start studying Reasons for or against annexation. Incorrect d. Aguinaldo argued that the United States was betraying its own values by annexing the Philippines. List the reasons for and against annexation of the Philippines. As many as 200,000 Filipino civilians died from violence, famine, and disease. (July 4th, 1821- Speech to the House of Rep.). Step 5: Debate-- When … What would he /she not be willing to compromise on? The Philippines did not have a stable government and were very limited. Annexation of the Philippine Islands Page 1 of 5 Spoden's Documents Annexation of the Philippine Islands Below you will find six letters expressing opinions on whether or not the United States should annex (bring under its control) the Philippine Islands in 1898. Performance & security by Cloudflare, Please complete the security check to access. The USA was simply too racist back then to allow Philippinos representation in the US Congress. With the Philippines, the U.S. … Does anyone actually believe Charlie Manger: 'Nobody was trying to make the rich richer' during corporate bailouts? • A war of conquest will unite the nation and create a sense of pride among all inhabitants of the US. The treaty allowed the U.S. to purchase California and other areas from Mexico on the condition that Americans would honor Mexican culture and values. Social Education , 7 (November/December 1999): 402-408. Driven by greed, history is written by the wants and desires of nations to become larger, wealthier, at the expense of those smaller forms a never-ending cycle from the time of the earliest writings, to … While the US did not keep Cuba in the deal with Spain, America did opt to retain control of the Philippines, for economic reasons. to discuss … But expansionists in the U.S. government … In addition to this, if the U.S. did not annex the Philippines, then other countries such as Germany or Japan could have easily taken over due to the lack of government in the Philippines. The Anti-Imperialist League doesn’t believe that Abraham Lincoln would have supported the annexation of Philippines as he believed that “Our reliance is in the love of liberty which God has planted in us. Step 4: Presenting the Views from the Documents. Spell. Annexation Of The Philippines Case Study. Driven by greed, history is written by the wants and desires of nations to become larger, wealthier, at the expense of those smaller forms a never-ending cycle from the time of the earliest writings, to … Gravity. Germany and other countries like it then had a chance to expand their empires even more. QUESTION: Describe the debate, pro and con, in the following documents about the annexation of the Philippines. Philippines) we could set up naval bases to protect our trading routes and allow ships to refuel. Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now. If you are on a personal connection, like at home, you can run an anti-virus scan on your device to make sure it is not infected with malware. • Match. Remember the World post 9/11 folks, and the Global War against Terrorism - do you remember living in that climate ? Letter #1: FROM: Commodore Dewey TO: William McKinley, President of the United States Mr. … What are some of the reasons on the other side of the argument? The Philippines did not have a stable government and were weak. Philippine-American War, war between the United States and Filipino revolutionaries from 1899 to 1902, an insurrection that may be seen as a continuation of the Philippine Revolution against Spanish rule. New territories would be organized into republican states and … Through the annexation of the Philippines, new market opportunities would have been created. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. Annexation of the Philippines Created the American Empire The history of the world is one filled with war, brutality, and greed from nations exerting their might to gain power or land. The annexation of Texas was highly controversial amongst the states and contributed to widening American sectionalism leading up to the Civil War. Jun (Jay) Park Jhp2253 Professor Seaholm 09/25/2015 3 Reasons Against the US Annexation of the Philippines During the late 19 th century, there were a lot of attempts at expansion for many reasons. American imperialism consists of policies aimed at extending the political, economic and cultural influence of the United States over areas beyond its boundaries. Your IP: 188.165.236.187 PLAY. The blessings of liberty and republican government would spread peacefully over much of the North American continent. Jun (Jay) Park Jhp2253 Professor Seaholm 09/25/2015 3 Reasons Against the US Annexation of the Philippines During the late 19 th century, there were a lot of attempts at expansion for many reasons. Although Mexico had outlawed slavery completely years prior to Texas independence, slavery was allowed to continue in Mexican Texas, and continued to exist in Texas during its years as an independent Republic. ... protest against the cruelties and injustices from which they had suffered Philippine-American War, war between the United States and Filipino revolutionaries from 1899 to 1902, an insurrection that may be seen as a continuation of the Philippine Revolution against Spanish rule. The Intuitively I would think holding good protected places for large naval bases to patrol our trade routes seems like a much more critical interest. • Colonies would give us access to additional markets to take resources from and sell surplus products. However Philippine rebels had been waging guerrilla warfare against Spanish colonialism long before the U.S. became involved. The relative ease with which the United States dispatched the Spanish squadron in Manila Bay was only the beginning of what would become a nearly 50-year American presence in the Philippines. The Philippine-American War was an armed conflict fought from February 4, 1899 to July 2, 1902 between forces of the United States and Filipino revolutionaries led by President Emilio Aguinaldo.While the United States viewed the conflict as an insurrection standing in the way of extending its “manifest destiny” influence across the Pacific Ocean, Filipinos saw it as a … This is hypocritical to what we ourselves claim in our ideals expressed in our Declaration of Independence... the right to self govern. Also, the reasons … “Battle of Manila Bay” The decision by U.S. policymakers to annex the Philippines was not without domestic controversy. On February 4, 1899, just two days before the U.S. Senate ratified the treaty, fighting broke out between American forces and Filipino nationalists led by Emilio Aguinaldo who sought … 5. In this activity, students analyze primary documents from a variety of perspectives to gain an understanding of contemporary arguments for and against U.S. annexation of the Philippines at the turn of the twentieth century. Step 4: Presenting the Views from the Documents-- Each group member, pretending to be the person who wrote the assigned document, should present that person's view on annexation to the rest of the group. However, the Philippines seemed weak and unfit for governing itself. That person should make a chart with space for reasons for and against U.S. annexation of the Philippines. In 1893 the last monarch of Hawaii, Queen Lili'uokalani, was overthrown by party … Read More. 1. I believe Beveridge mainly wants the Philippines for their economic wealth they could provide. Another way to prevent getting this page in the future is to use Privacy Pass. What arguments are offered between those who favor annexation and those opposed? You may need to download version 2.0 now from the Chrome Web Store. For these reasons of strategic, economic, political, social, and moral expansion and growth of the United States there was a favorable opinion for the Philippines annexation as desired by imperialists like Mahan, Roosevelt, and Schurman. confidently appeal against the fantastic and wicked scheme of colonial expansion, the adoption of which will change our form of government and will bring nothing but disaster. Policymaker: Someone who sets the plan pursued by … When the Hawaiian islands were formally annexed by the United States in 1898, the event marked end of a lengthy internal struggle between native Hawaiians and white American businessmen for control of the Hawaiian government. A factor in the Texas annexation discussions in the United States was the realization of the northern states that there would be two new slave state Senators when Texas was admitted. If the Filipinos are not in support of this annexation, they will most assuredly fight us that will result in unnecessary violence and bloodshed of both American soldiers and Filipinos, whether you think them civilized or uncivilized. When war was declared, the Asiatic Squadron of the U.S. Navy, under the command of Admiral George Dewey, sailed immediately for the Philippines. What online tender platforms would you recommend to look for tenders, namely for infrastructure and construction tenders? "We must on no account let the islands go. Whether it is to show off the image of a stronger power with larger nations and colonies, or even just because other countries are doing it too, expansions and colonization was a … Now he has regrets. The United States, as well as other countries felt the Philippines needed “help” forming a government, and ruling themselves. ln the first days we were not sure if the US was there to liberate or occupy the Filipino people. An Anti-Imperialist League was formed to rally American public opinion against the annexation. Annexation Philippines Case Study The U.S. should not annex the Philippines because the Philippine people are very experienced in speaking their own language and also having their own currency which means that they are capable of self ruling. Move on to his consideration of the ideological rationale behind the policy.] . It, however, met opposition, mainly against the annexation of the Philippines. Step 3: Choosing a recorder. The only real true reasons I know is that some people in the US believed we were doing to the Phillippines what the British did to us and we fought with them to get our own independence so why should we try to take away someone elses? Aguinaldo led the Filipinos in the war against the United States. What are the two best reasons to After its defeat in the Spanish-American War of 1898, Spain ceded its longstanding colony of the Philippines to the United States in the Treaty of Paris. While some anti-imperialists understood the connection between the United States's military campaign in the Philippines and the horrific treatment of people of color in … It was to have a presence in Asia for trade there. Few believed that the Philippines themselves offered a crucial commercial advantage to the U.S., but many saw them as a crucial way station to Asia. Some Americans thought that the annex would only make the United States stronger, but others didn't like the idea of controlling overseas territories. … Mexico broke off diplomatic relations with the U.S. in 1845 over the issue, which eventually led to the Mexican-American war the following year. The Monroe Doctrine was supposed to be the major interest, but your question makes me wonder. In fact, he led the opposition to this in the Philippines. GEORGE HOAR : The Lust for Empire [Hoar begins with a lengthy discussion of whether imperialism was constitutional. STUDY. Annexation of the Philippines. If the Filipinos are not in support of this annexation, they will most assuredly fight us that will result in unnecessary violence and bloodshed of both American soldiers and Filipinos, whether you think them civilized or uncivilized. Americans relied on newspapers. If the Supreme Court refuses Trump's effort to block his tax return what will happen next? Flashcards. "The Philippine-American War, 1899‚Äì1902 ." He wants supremacy in the Pacific- something that military bases on the island could provide. An Anti-Imperialist League was formed to rally American public opinion against the annexation. What are the two best reasons to “Had we no interests in China,” noted one advocate of annexation, “the possession of the Philippines would be meaningless.” In the Paris Peace negotiations, President William McKinley demanded the Philippines to avoid giving them … The United States fought harsh battles against Spain and the Philippines. The 1897 Petition Against the Annexation of Hawaii Background. The American eagle has landed in the Philippines. Schurz's anti-expansionist pronouncements were consistent over the decades, combining democratic principles with cultural bias. Fighting, however, began in the distant Philippine Islands. Americans who advocated annexation … They lost thousands of men and need compensation. Our defense is in the spirit which prizes liberty as the heritage of all men in all lands” (Halsall 1). He believed that the United States should never govern any land undemocratically; therefore, any newly acquired … Cloudflare Ray ID: 627a8b3b8bf70893 Please enable Cookies and reload the page.